Seller Rating Quick Reference
| Rating Level | Review Volume | What It Means | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.5+ stars | 500+ reviews | Proven, reliable, consistent | Safe choice for any order |
| 4.0-4.5 stars | 200+ reviews | Good but may have minor issues | Read recent reviews for current status |
| 3.5-4.0 stars | Any | Mixed quality, inconsistent | Check QC photos carefully; consider alternatives |
| Under 3.5 stars | Any | Significant issues or new seller | Avoid unless you have specific reason to trust |
| 5.0 stars | Under 50 reviews | New or untested seller | Wait for more reviews or start with a small test order |
Red Flags to Avoid
Seller not listed in the official spreadsheet
Sudden drop in recent review ratings
Prices far below the category average without explanation
No recent reviews in the last 60 days
Inconsistent QC photos across community orders
Strict no-exchange policy
Unresponsive to pre-order questions
Positive Signals to Look For
High Volume + Recent Reviews
Sellers with 500+ reviews and activity in the last 30 days have been tested by the community and are currently active.
Consistent QC Photos
When community QC photos from the same seller look similar, the seller has good production control.
Category Specialization
Sellers who focus on one category often have better quality than generalists. Look for specialists in the category you want.
Responsive Communication
Sellers who answer questions about sizing and stock are easier to work with, especially for first-time buyers.